|
||

Japan is considering whether Internet service providers should block access to websites publishing personal information stolen in cyberattacks, raising questions about the limits of government intervention and the constitutional protection of private communications.
The Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications convened an expert working group for its first meeting on November 20 to examine ways to limit the harm caused by leaked data. The review follows a November 6 government emergency cybersecurity package calling for stronger measures against the spread of stolen information.
Blocking raises constitutional concerns. Restricting access to designated websites could require ISPs to examine users’ connection destinations, potentially conflicting with Japan’s constitutional guarantee of secrecy of communications. Ministry officials acknowledged the legal difficulty but suggested that blocking might be permissible under certain circumstances.
The ministry pointed to increasingly sophisticated cyberattacks, including those involving artificial intelligence, and the growing volume of exposed personal information as reasons to reconsider the available protections.
Experts questioned whether blocking would be effective enough to justify its costs. According to Sankei and NHK, participants warned against treating the measure as a comprehensive solution. They raised concerns about its effects on communications privacy and whether the practical benefits would meet expectations.
The review is not limited to ISP blocking. Nikkei reports that the working group is also examining domain suspensions and website takedowns.
These approaches would affect different parts of the Internet infrastructure. ISP blocking restricts access through participating networks, while domain suspension can disrupt access through a website’s domain name. Removing content at the hosting level addresses the material itself. Each approach carries different technical consequences and could place responsibilities on ISPs, registries, registrars or hosting providers.
Japan already permits voluntary ISP blocking of websites containing child sexual abuse material under narrowly defined circumstances. Applying similar restrictions to sites distributing stolen personal information would extend the discussion into a different category of online harm, with its own legal and practical questions.
No blocking requirement has been adopted. The working group is expected to deliver an interim report in early 2027. Its conclusions could help determine whether Japan pursues ISP blocking, domain-level measures, website takedowns or other restrictions on the distribution of stolen data.
Sponsored byWhoisXML API
Sponsored byVerisign
Sponsored byRadix
Sponsored byIPv4.Global
Sponsored byVerisign
Sponsored byCSC
Sponsored byDNIB.com